Quantcast
Channel: AsiaOne
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 8682

Workers' housing issues need immediate attention

$
0
0

Singapore is known for its squeaky-clean roads and parks pruned to perfection.

But an ugly side exists.

It is the underbelly of filthy and cramped shophouses, apartments and temporary dorms where many foreign workers live.

On Tuesday night, a spot check by foreign worker group Migrant Workers' Centre (MWC) and The Straits Times found more than 50 construction workers from Bangladesh and India cramped in two small apartments in Selegie Road.

The men slept shoulder to shoulder, amid rotting food and soiled clothes.

Deplorable dormitory conditions for foreign workers

Click on thumbnail to view. Story continues after photos. The Straits Times, The New Paper

  • Bad living conditions in a foreign workers dormitory at Kampong Ampat, MacPherson.
  • More than 50 foreign workers cramped into a room about the size of a two-room HDB flat.
  • 180 workers – from China, India, Bangladesh, Thailand and Myanmar lived in this 'container city' off Mandai Road.
  • Ministry of Manpower (MOM) officials at the ‘container city’ off Mandai Road on 1 July 2010
  • This photo shows the fans and a TV set which were left by the workers at the Mandai compound.
  •  Foreign workers living in a container in Jurong. Such living conditions are deemed inappropriate accomodation for foreign workers
  • Rotting food, soiled clothes and bags were strewn on the grimy floors of the units located in Selegie Centre near Little India.
  • Shower facilities in a deplorable state in a foreign workers’ dormitory.
  • Inspection by NGO Migrant Workers' Centre which received a complaint from a workers who says 120 workers are being squeezed into two apartments in Selegie Centre.
  • Dormitories near Punngol
  • A foreign worker walks past a row of urinals, one broken, as seen in the toilet of a dormitory hear Punggol.
  • A foreign worker preparing dinner in the zinc-roofed shacks at their construction-site dormitories near Punggol
  • Workers at a construction site in Punggol bathing in rudimentary toilets, just metres away from spanking new Housing Board flats they are building.
  • Inspection by NGO Migrant Workers' Centre which received a complaint from a workers who says 120 workers are being squeezed into two apartments in Selegie Centre.
  • Inspection by NGO Migrant Workers' Centre which received a complaint from a workers who says 120 workers are being squeezed into two apartments in Selegie Centre.
  • Inspection by NGO Migrant Workers' Centre which received a complaint from a workers who says 120 workers are being squeezed into two apartments in Selegie Centre.
  • Inspection by NGO Migrant Workers' Centre which received a complaint from a workers who says 120 workers are being squeezed into two apartments in Selegie Centre.
  • Inspection by NGO Migrant Workers' Centre which received a complaint from a workers who says 120 workers are being squeezed into two apartments in Selegie Centre.
  • Inspection by NGO Migrant Workers' Centre which received a complaint from a workers who says 120 workers are being squeezed into two apartments in Selegie Centre.
  • Inspection by NGO Migrant Workers' Centre which received a complaint from a workers who says 120 workers are being squeezed into two apartments in Selegie Centre.
  • A makeshift hut in Geylang.
  • A makeshift hut in Geylang.
  • Inspection by NGO Migrant Workers' Centre which received a complaint from a workers who says 120 workers are being squeezed into two apartments in Selegie Centre.
  • Inspection by NGO Migrant Workers' Centre which received a complaint from a workers who says 120 workers are being squeezed into two apartments in Selegie Centre.
  • A makeshift hut in Geylang.

The Manpower Ministry (MOM) is now investigating the workers' employers for housing them in unacceptable conditions and not paying the men.

The employers face fines of up to $10,000, and/or up to 12 months in prison. But there are many more unscrupulous bosses who go scot-free for subjecting their workers to bad housing.

In recent months, The Straits Times has published several reports on unhygienic and over- crowded foreign worker housing.

At the living quarters of a Punggol Housing Board construction site, hundreds of workers use choked and broken urinals.

Over at Tuas View Square, about 5,000 workers live in more than 10 factory-converted dormitories which are infested with rats and mosquitoes.

The Government is acutely aware of the problem and has taken important steps to rectify the situation.

Nine purpose-built dorms, which come with cafeterias and basketball courts, will be built over the next two years. They will add around 100,000 beds to the existing 200,000 in about 40 big dorms.

To move workers to proper dorms, the Urban Redevelopment Authority stopped the building of temporary dormitories in a dozen industrial estates last Friday.

Non-Malaysian workers from the marine and process sectors, which include the chemicals and pharmaceutical sectors, will also not be allowed to live in public housing from next year.

Good dormitory conditions for foreign workers

Click on thumbnail to view. Story continues after photos. The Straits Times, The New Paper

  • Ramalingam Radha Krishnan uses his notebook computer to connect to the internet via the Wi-Fi at the foreign workers' dormitory at Sing Moh Electrical Engineering, 85 Tagore Lane.
  • The 150 workers employed by the company have a Wi-Fi connection and a rooftop area for their meals; they are also provided with televisions, washing machines and dryers.
  • Foreign workers exit and enter the dormitory via a gated entrance.
  • Foreign workers enjoy a game of futsal at the courts after returning from work at Tuas View Dormitory - Singapore's biggest dormitory which can house 16,800 workers.
  • Foreign workers sit around along the road and grass patch as they enjoy an outdoor screening of a movie after coming back to the dormitory after work.
  • Generic photograph of foreign workers doing their daily activities and the dormitory staff working at Tuas View Dormitory - Singapore's biggest dormitory which can house 16,800 workers.
  • A foreign worker shaves in the toilet.
  • A foreign worker gets ready for a shower in the toilet.
  • Chief security supervisor Mr Parameswaran (in blue) from Crete Security patrols on a segway around the domitory blocks as foreign workers are seen using their mobile phones and smoking along the roadside kerb.
  • The dormitory also offers catering service for Chinese and Indian cuisine daily at the kitchen for those who do not want to cook or buy their dinner from outside.
  • Rice cooking in the cookers on the shelves during dinner time at the dormitory's kitchen.
  • Foreign workers are seen preparing and cooking chapati and curry for dinner at the dormitory's kitchen.
  • A foreign workers sits on the stairs with his mobile phone as others are seen preparing and cooking dinner at the dormitory's kitchen.
  • Mr Belan Hossain (left), 26, from Bangladesh, cooks fish curry at the dormitory's kitchen for dinner.
  • Foreign workers from Henan, China, Mr Ye Ji Qing (in black), 36, and Mr Xiong Nian Bin (right), 42, play a game of pool in the dormitory's recreation room.
  • Foreign workers sit around along the road and grass patch as they enjoy an outdoor screening of a movie after coming back to the domitory after work.
  • Foreign workers sit around along the road and grass patch as they enjoy an outdoor screening of a movie after coming back to the domitory after work.
  • Foreign workers exercise inside the dormitory's gymnasium.
  • Foreign workers exercise inside the dormitory's gymnasium.
  • Foreign worker from India Mr Jagadeesh (in red singlet), 24, lifts weights inside the dormitory's gymnasium as others are also seen exercising in the background.
  • Other foreign workers exercising inside the dormitory's gymnasium stare as Mr Satish Kumar (right), 27, who is from South India, strikes a pose for the camera.
  • Data controller Mr Umapathy, 31, does his work inside the data control and security office with LCD TV screens beaming images from cameras all over the domitory seen in the background.
  • A small group of foreign workers who are new to the dormitory gets briefed in the data control and security office which monitors what is going on at the site as well as entry pass clearance.
  • Foreign workers shop at Elim Trading, a hardware shop located within the dormitory's commercial shopping arcade that will have 40 shops when fully operational.
  • Foreign workers shop for their groceries at Ajmal Super Mart Pte Ltd.
  • A fishmonger cuts up fish for customers at the wet market located within Ajmal Super Mart Pte Ltd in the dormitory
  • Foreign workers from India Mr Govindan (in green), 26, and Mr Murugesan (in brown striped shirt), 32, buy fish at the wet market located within Ajmal Super Mart Pte Ltd in the dormitory.
  • A foreign worker shops for prawns at the wet market located within Ajmal Super Mart Pte Ltd in the dormitory.
  • Foreign workers pay for their groceries at Ajmal Super Mart Pte Ltd.
  • Foreign workers Mr Veeraragavan (left), 35, and Mr Saravanan (right), 35, from Tamil Nadu, India, have their dinner of curry dhal and rice at the Tuas View Food Court located within the dormitory.
  • Foreign workers Mr Veeraragavan (centre, left), 35, and Mr Saravanan (centre, right), 35, from Tamil Nadu, India, have their dinner of curry dhal and rice at the Tuas View Food Court located within the dormitory.
  • 46-year-old Madam Lai Shou Yan (bottom right corner) serves up a plate of mixed vegetables with white rice to a foreign worker at the Tuas View Food Court located within the dormitory. Now a Singapore citizen, Madam Lai was originally from Shandong, China, and has been working in Singapore for the past 17 years.
  • Mr Bimol Thapkort (right), 45, and Inthajan Sawaj (left), 46, who are foreign workers from Thailand, enjoy their beer as they watch a Thai movie from a mobile phone.
  • Foreign workers buy cans of beer at the GGM Beer Garden located within the dormitory, as they enjoy a Bruce Lee movie projected against a white wall.
  • Foreign workers chill out with their dinner, snacks and beer at the GGM Beer Garden located within the dormitory, as they enjoy a Bruce Lee movie projected against a white wall.
  • Foreign workers chill out with their dinner, snacks and beer at the GGM Beer Garden located within the dormitory, as they enjoy a Bruce Lee movie projected against a white wall.
  • A group of friends enjoy a game of futsal at the courts after returning from work.
  • A group of friends enjoy a game of futsal at the courts after returning from work.
  • A foreign worker is seen shifting empty large white containers in the laundry room with the industrial washing machines and dryers seen in the background. The containers are used to transport the laundry.
  • A group of foreign workers pack clean clothes after being washed at the packing and distribution room for collection at 8pm in the dormitory.
  • A group of foreign workers pack clean clothes after being washed at the packing and distribution room for collection at 8pm in the dormitory.

But these improvements will not be felt for some time. In the meantime, concrete steps should be taken to fix the situation for the tens of thousands of workers who continue to live in deplorable conditions.

There are about 700 temporary dorms housing some 100,000 low-skilled foreign workers. The rest are housed elsewhere, such as in HDB flats, apartments or temporary quarters on worksites.

Economists and foreign worker activists said the authorities must step up checks and impose harsher penalties on errant bosses.

Nanyang Technological University economist Walter Theseira said bad bosses know that the "statistical likelihood that one will be caught for housing workers in substandard conditions from purely random checks is very low".

"The penalties are presumably not a severe enough deterrent given the low likelihood of getting caught," said Dr Theseira.

In the first six months this year, MOM conducted about 360 inspections, and took action against about 600 employers for housing violations. Some were just warned and most were fined.

MWC's chairman Yeo Guat Kwang said the authorities must detect, investigate and prosecute bosses who break the law to the fullest extent.

"Only in such an environment will it not be at all worthwhile for anyone to consider gaming or circumventing our laws, no matter what he stands to gain as a result," he said.

Mr John Gee, head of research of Transient Workers Count Too, said MOM can work with non-governmental organisations to conduct high-profile raids of bad housing places.

Home sweat home

Click on thumbnail to view. Story continues after photos. The New Paper, Mr Ahmad

  • What used to be home for his family of five became a "dormitory" for at least 20 Chinese nationals after a businessman rented his flat out to six subtenants.
  • A stack of fliers handwritten in Chinese sought subtenants for the flat, which was described as having "good Internet connection and in pleasant surroundings".
  • Under HDB guidelines, a maximum of nine subtenants are allowed in a four-room flat.
  • Mr Ahmad had applied successfully to the HDB to rent his flat to six subtenants before leaving Singapore.
  • He said that he did not know much about them, except that they were work-permit holders from China.
  • He rented out his flat to them for $2,700 a month.
  • "They seemed okay. I trusted them based on the documents they produced. They said they just wanted a roof over their heads," he said.
  • Mr Ahmad found out from his neighbour that she saw people with "unfamiliar faces spitting along the corridor one morning".
  • Mr Ahmad's flat was left in bad shape. There were greasy kitchen tabletops and grimy toilet walls.
  • Of the six original subtenants, only two were left when TNP visited the flat two weeks ago.
  • Two tenants claimed to have nothing to do with the illegal subletting, instead pointing one of the original six, a man they knew only as Mr Zhang, as the "mastermind".
  • "The storeroom had been converted into a bedroom and there was even a wooden partition separating the dining area from the living room to create another bedroom," said Mr Ahmad.
  • Bunk bed frames were left stacked in the bedrooms.
  • "I will never sublet my flat again. There is no trust left," said Mr Ahmad.

More importantly, workers should also be empowered to speak up against ill-treatment.

One way is for MOM to expand its Temporary Job Scheme to whistle-blowers. The scheme allows foreign workers to find a new job while waiting for their employment-related claims to be settled.

Workers should also be educated about help channels for them. MWC runs a 24-hour helpline for workers. But it is unclear if workers know about this.

Raising awareness on this front will help combat the problem.

MOM could conduct a dedicated short course to introduce foreign workers to their rights and organisations which can help them.

Currently, employment rights are covered in compulsory safety courses for foreign workers but they are not explained in detail.

Singaporeans can also help by reporting unfair treatment of foreign workers to the authorities.

Said Mr Yeo: "It takes the whole community to truly eradicate injustice to migrant workers. If all of us do our part, we can better conditions for migrant workers in Singapore."

ameltan@sph.com.sg


This article was first published on November 21, 2014.
Get a copy of The Straits Times or go to straitstimes.com for more stories.


Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 8682

Trending Articles